What the well-known failures of FTX, Celsius, Voyager, BlockFi, Genesis and Mt. Gox teach about custody, yield products and being an unsecured creditor, and the equally real risks of property. Facts at event level; we did not re-check court records.
In brief - Counterparty risk is the risk that the firm holding or borrowing your assets cannot give them back. In crypto it has already happened several times at large scale. - Source note. The events below come from press and law-firm summaries found in searches on 15 November 2026; we did not open court dockets or administrators' notices. Recovery figures differ by source, date and class of claim, so check the dockets before relying on any number. - The lesson is about structure, not about one bad actor: who owns the coins, what you agreed to, and what happens in insolvency. - Moving into property removes this specific risk but replaces it with others. That trade-off is the honest reason some holders do it, and the honest reason others do not.
What happened, at event level
- Mt. Gox (2014). A large exchange collapsed in 2014; the commonly cited figure of about 850,000 bitcoin lost is the original amount, which our searches did not confirm. Creditor repayment is still not finished: a report dated 20 October 2026 (Cointelegraph, via search) says the Tokyo court approved moving the deadline from 31 October 2026 to 31 October 2027, the sixth extension since 2023. More than a decade later, creditors are still waiting.
- Voyager, Celsius, BlockFi (2022). Lenders that paid interest on deposited coins froze withdrawals and filed for Chapter 11: Voyager on 5 or 6 July 2022 (sources differ by a day; withdrawals reportedly frozen from 1 July), Celsius on 13 July 2022 (we could not confirm the date of its earlier withdrawal pause) and BlockFi on 28 November 2022.
- FTX (2022). FTX and Alameda filed for Chapter 11 in Delaware on 11 November 2022. Early in the case FTX reported identifying about USD 2.7 billion of customer assets against about USD 11.6 billion of customer balances (press reports of the filings).
- Genesis (2023). A lending arm in the same wave filed in January 2023 (exact day not found).
What customers eventually recovered differs sharply by case. In FTX, press reports of later distributions describe cumulative recoveries for several classes at or above 100% of the claim, but claims were fixed at November 2022 prices and the sources disagree on rounds and percentages, so we give no single figure. The point is not the final percentage: it is the years of waiting, the loss of control over timing and the fixed valuation date.
What these cases teach
1. Coins on an exchange are a claim, not a bearer asset. In an insolvency you are usually an unsecured creditor and wait in a queue; your claim may be fixed at a past price. 2. A yield product is a loan. When a platform pays interest on your deposit, it is lending your coins on. The yield is a payment for taking credit risk; see rental yield vs staking and lending yield. 3. Regulation changes the odds but does not remove the risk. MiCA authorisation in the EU and the licence regimes of other countries add rules on custody and segregation; they do not guarantee that a provider will never fail. 4. Self-custody moves the risk to you. Lost keys, phishing and wrong addresses are also losses, and there is no administrator to file with. 5. Concentration is the common thread. Holding most of your wealth with one provider is what turned a failure into a personal disaster.
Why some holders move into property
A flat is held in your name in a land registry, not on a platform's balance sheet. Its price can fall, but it does not disappear when a company fails, and it can be let or used. Some holders also value having a physical asset in a regulated registry system. Our article on what property gives a crypto holder and what it does not goes through the benefits.
Property has its own counterparties
| Risk | Crypto platform failure | Property |
|---|---|---|
| Who can fail | The platform | The developer (for off-plan), the agent, the seller, the escrow holder |
| What you hold | A claim against the firm | A title in a registry, if the deed is registered |
| Liquidity | Often minutes, until withdrawals stop | Months, and a percentage of the price in exit costs |
| Typical loss | Whole balance in the failure | Price decline, defects, legal title problems, fraud |
| Protection | Court claim; sometimes none | Notary and registry; lawyer's checks; insurance |
Bank deposits carry a deposit guarantee in the EU (EUR 100,000 per depositor per bank under the EU directive, per the EBA and national authorities; check your country), and property has no such guarantee against a fall in price. Off-plan purchases from a developer that fails are a real counterparty risk of their own, and an unverified listing can be fraud.
A practical response that does not require property
- Split custody: not all coins at one provider, and understand what each provider's terms say about segregation.
- Do not lend coins you cannot afford to wait for.
- If you move into property, use an independent lawyer and a registered deed. See what property gives a crypto holder and the decision checklist.
FAQ
Is property safer than crypto? It is safer from one risk (a platform failing) and exposed to others (illiquidity, local law, price). It is not risk-free.
Did customers of these firms get their money back? It differs by case. FTX distributions were reported to reach or pass 100% of claims for some classes, valued at November 2022 prices, after years of waiting; Mt. Gox creditors were still waiting in late 2026. Check the administrators' notices for any specific claim.
Should I keep coins on a regulated exchange? That is an individual choice; a licence is a reason to ask about segregation, not a guarantee.
How we help
We help you prepare questions, calculate the full cost and connect you with independent local lawyers and tax advisers. See the calculators. Information only, not legal, tax or investment advice; figures are indicative as of October-November 2026 and change. Crypto and property can both lose value.